The Title: Which is more appealing?

I’m doing an experiment on what title sounds better. I’ve chosen that I want to sell a toaster. But I’m not sure what title would grab your eye – here are some options:
1. A $5 Toaster
2. Good Toaster – $5
3. The Best Toast You’ve Ever Tasted
4. Vintage Toaster – $5
5. My Grandma’s Toaster for only $5
6. $5 for Old Toaster
What would grab your eye?
Creative Commons Image by Donovan Govan